How to Choose a Property Manager in Australia: The 8 Questions You Must Ask

Choosing a property manager is one of the most consequential decisions an Australian investment property owner makes: and one of the most under-researched. Most investors spend weeks analysing suburbs, yields, and comparable sales, then spend 20 minutes choosing who will actually manage their asset. The result is predictable: bad managers cost investors more money in lost rent, poor tenant selection, and maintenance neglect than a bad suburb selection ever would.

Here’s how to choose a property manager in Australia who will actually protect and grow your investment.

What Does a Property Manager Actually Do?

Before evaluating managers, understand what you’re buying. A good property manager handles:

• Tenant acquisition: Advertising, screening applications, conducting reference checks, selecting the right tenant
• Lease management: Drafting legally compliant tenancy agreements, managing renewals, handling rent increases in line with market rates and state legislation
• Rent collection: Chasing arrears, processing payments, disbursing rent to you
• Maintenance coordination: Receiving maintenance requests, coordinating qualified trades, managing urgent repairs within legislative timeframes
• Inspections: Conducting entry, routine (usually quarterly), and exit inspections with written reports and photos
• Compliance: Ensuring the property meets current state tenancy law, smoke alarm regulations, pool safety compliance, and any applicable rental minimum standards
• Dispute resolution: Managing tenant disputes through the relevant state tribunal (VCAT, NCAT, QCAT, etc.) when required

The 8 Questions to Ask Before Signing a Management Agreement

1. How Many Properties Does Each Property Manager Handle?

This is the single most important question. A property manager handling 120–150 properties is at the limit of what is manageable. A manager with 200+ properties is almost certainly giving each landlord poor service. Ask specifically: “How many properties does the person who will manage my property personally manage?” Not the office: the individual.

The best property managers typically handle 60–90 properties. At this level, they know their tenants, respond to maintenance within hours (not days), and proactively manage lease renewals before they expire. Above 150, the reactive overwhelms the proactive.

2. What Is Your Average Vacancy Period?

Ask for the average number of days between tenants across their portfolio. A well-run agency in a reasonable market should achieve less than 14 days average vacancy. If they can’t tell you (or won’t) that’s a significant red flag. Your vacancy rate is directly correlated to the quality of tenant management and the proactiveness of the lease renewal process.

3. How Do You Handle Maintenance?

Get specific. Who authorises maintenance? What is the threshold above which they must contact you before proceeding? (Answer should be: everything above $X (typically $300–500) requires your approval, with exceptions for genuine emergencies.) Do they use their own trades or independent ones? (Warning sign: agencies with in-house trades sometimes recommend unnecessary work.)

Ask to see a sample maintenance request report. A good manager documents what was requested, what was done, by whom, and the cost: all in writing, with photos.

4. How Often Do You Conduct Routine Inspections?

Routine inspections should occur every 3–4 months in most states (check your state’s maximum frequency under tenancy law). Ask to see a sample routine inspection report. It should include: written condition notes for every room, photos of key areas, any maintenance items identified, and the manager’s assessment of tenant care. A two-sentence inspection report is worth nothing.

5. What Are Your Full Fee Structures. Including Every Line Item?

Property management fees in Australia range from 5% to 12% of gross rent depending on state and market. But the management percentage is often not the most significant cost. Ask specifically about:

• Letting fee: Typically 1–2 weeks rent per new tenancy
• Lease renewal fee: Some agencies charge 0.5–1 week rent every time a lease is renewed (this can add up significantly over a 5-year hold)
• Routine inspection fee: Some agencies charge per inspection
• Maintenance coordination fee: Some agencies add a percentage on top of trade costs
• VCAT/tribunal attendance fee: Per-attendance fees if they have to attend a hearing on your behalf
• Advertising fee: Separate charge for listing the property on realestate.com.au and domain.com.au

Get the full fee schedule in writing before signing anything. A seemingly low management percentage with high ancillary fees can cost more than a higher percentage with no add-ons.

6. How Long Are Your Tenancy Agreements?

Fixed-term agreements of 12 months are standard. Ask how they handle tenants who request shorter terms (6 months) or longer terms (2 years). Both can be appropriate in certain circumstances, but the manager should have a view on what serves your interests best in the current market.

7. How Do You Handle Rent Arrears?

Ask for their exact arrears process: at what point do they contact the tenant, at what point do they issue a breach notice, and at what point do they initiate tribunal proceedings? The answer should follow your state’s tenancy legislation timeline: but within those constraints, a proactive manager acts immediately, not weeks later. Rent arrears left unaddressed for weeks becomes months; months becomes write-offs.

8. Can You Provide Landlord References?

Ask for contact details of 2–3 landlords whose properties they manage. Call them. Ask: how responsive are they? Have they had vacancy periods? How did they handle the last maintenance issue? Have they ever had a problem tenant, and how was it managed? Three minutes on the phone with a real landlord is worth more than three hours reviewing the agency’s marketing.

Red Flags to Walk Away From

• They can’t tell you how many properties each individual manager handles
• Vague or verbal answers to fee questions: insist on written fee schedules
• No routine inspection report template to show you
• Average vacancy above 21 days with no clear explanation
• Pressure to sign quickly or “lock in” before you’ve had time to compare
• No dedicated property manager: just a rotating pool of staff who handle your calls
• In-house maintenance trades with no transparency on markup

Self-Managing vs Professional Management

Some investors self-manage: particularly for a single local investment property. The cost saving (typically $2,500–5,000/year on a median-rent property) is real. So is the time cost and legislative risk. Australian tenancy legislation is complex, state-specific, and changes regularly. The cost of a tribunal hearing, a tenancy database dispute, or a compliance breach can far exceed several years of management fees. For investors with more than one property, investors who live interstate or overseas from their property, or investors without significant time to devote to management, professional management is almost always the right call.

See our guide on property management fees in Australia for a detailed breakdown of what’s reasonable to pay and how to compare agencies.

Frequently Asked Questions. How to Choose a Property Manager Australia

The right property manager is the difference between an investment that runs itself and one that constantly demands your attention and money. Take the hiring decision as seriously as the property purchase itself: because over a 10-year hold, the manager’s performance has more impact on your net return than almost any other variable you can control.

One Property at a time
Brick by Brick 🧱

General Advice Warning: This article is general in nature and does not constitute personal financial advice. Please consult a licensed financial adviser before making investment decisions.